Fans Brutally Trash TNA President Carlos Silva – “Resign” & “Change Creative” Flood Replies
While it's rare for wrestling fans to directly call out a company President by name, TNA's Carlos Silva has become a lightning rod for frustration in 2026.
Once seen as a fresh face bringing stability and the big AMC TV deal, Silva is now catching major backlash online — especially in replies to his own tweets and across wrestling social media.
The Growing Frustration
Recent replies to Silva's posts (like his May 31 tweet about Santino in Italy) are filled with blunt demands:
"Change the creative dawg"
"Get rid of Dreamer and Delirious"
"You should resign at this point..."
Complaints calling the product "unwatchable" since the AMC move, with ratings reportedly sliding from an early ~250k peak down toward 175k.
Fans are pointing fingers at creative (heavily tied to Tommy Dreamer), repetitive booking, weak storylines, and decisions like pulling talent from AEW/indie matches over "partner conflicts." Some have even dubbed it a full "Fuck TNA" movement.
The YouTube Angle
One vocal critic, Markyd123, has basically turned his channel into a dedicated anti-TNA hub. His video "50 Reasons TNA Wrestling is STRUGGLING!" (posted late May 2026, ~28k views) rips into:
Lack of storylines
Boring roster
Lifeless presentation
Overuse of factions like the System
Creative under Dreamer/Delirious
And yes — calls out Carlos Silva directly as part of the problem
The video ends with a plea to fire the current creative team before TNA becomes a permanent "developmental brand."
Carlos’ true job
Bottom Line
It's a tough spot for Silva — he's making business decisions (protecting partnerships, TV stability) but the on-screen product isn't winning fans back fast enough.
In wrestling, when ratings dip and the shows feel flat, the guy at the top gets the heat... even if it's unusual to see it this direct.
