The WrestleVoice Milk Carton: Major WWE & AEW Stars Who Have Vanished

WrestleVoice milk carton style poster reading “Missing Professional Wrestlers.” Vintage missing-persons design with WWE and AEW sections filled with anonymous wrestler silhouettes.

Every wrestling fan has been there: you’re watching WWE Monday Night Raw, SmackDown, or AEW Dynamite, and a thought suddenly hits you—“Wait a second, what happened to that person?”

Between massive rosters, creative resets, Hollywood side quests, and mysterious backstage pauses, some of the biggest names in the business have quietly pulled a disappearing act.

So, we’re slapping their faces on the side of the WrestleVoice Milk Carton to see if anyone out there has spotted them.


THE WRESTLEVOICE MILK CARTON

VOL. 1: THE MISSING STARS EDITION

Have you seen these wrestlers? Between Hollywood side quests, mystery hiatuses, and creative reset buttons, some of the biggest names in WWE and AEW have completely vanished from weekly television. Here are the top names currently lost on the WrestleVoice Milk Carton.
WWE MISSING PERSON
Drew McIntyre
Last Seen: Losing an Unsanctioned Match to Jacob Fatu at WrestleMania 42 back in April.
Suspected Whereabouts: After wrapping up some Hollywood filming commitments, "Hollywood Drew" popped up ringside at a Pro-Wrestling: EVE indie show in London this week, posting that he misses the smaller scene while still refusing to give a WWE comeback date.
Reward for Return: A main-event program the second he decides he’s done scouting UK indies.
WWE MISSING PERSON
Seth Rollins
Last Seen: Wrapping up his blockbuster SummerSlam showdown with Roman Reigns nearly four months ago.
Suspected Whereabouts: Completely off the grid while his former Vision cohorts run wild on Raw. With Survivor Series: WarGames right around the corner, fans are scouring every frame of TV for a hint of "The Visionary."
Reward for Return: A fresh designer suit and an immediate spot in the WarGames chaos.
WWE MISSING PERSON
Naomi
Last Seen: Vacating the Women's World Championship on Raw in August 2025 after announcing her pregnancy with Jimmy Uso.
Suspected Whereabouts: Plotting a "Proceed with Caution" comeback from home. With The Bloodline and The 946 heading toward WarGames—and The Usos dropping a major teaser on Raw this week—the clock is ticking on her return.
Reward for Return: Evening the odds against Jaida Parker and The 946.
WWE TAG & MIDCARD ALERT
Rusev & The Street Profits
Last Seen: Rusev hasn’t wrestled on Raw since July’s Intercontinental Title No. 1 Contender’s Gauntlet, while Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins have been largely MIA on weekly TV since dropping the World Tag Team Titles.
Suspected Whereabouts: Hanging out in catering waiting for the tag and midcard divisions to hit the reset button.
Reward for Return: Actual television time on Mondays and Fridays.

AEW MISSING PERSONS

AEW MISSING PERSON
Sammy Guevara
Last Seen: Losing the ROH World Tag Team Championships alongside The Beast Mortos at CMLL’s Viernes Espectacular back in June.
Suspected Whereabouts: Vlogging, raising a family, and waiting by the phone while Tony Khan figures out where he fits into a stacked roster.
Reward for Return: A fresh storyline that doesn't require jumping off a 20-foot ladder.
AEW MISSING PERSON
Ruby Soho
Last Seen: Taking maternity leave in April 2024 before welcoming her baby with Angelo Parker.
Suspected Whereabouts: Running their wrestling-and-board-game café (Victory Roll) in Indiana and working toward her in-ring clearance, despite being off TV for over two years.
Reward for Return: A long-awaited entrance set to Rancid.
AEW MISSING PERSON
Kamille
Last Seen: Making a blink-and-you-missed-it four-day cameo in April 2026—winning on the Dynasty: Zero Hour pre-show and losing a TBS Title match to Willow Nightingale on Dynamite—before vanishing again.
Suspected Whereabouts: Still officially under AEW contract, sitting at home with zero creative plans in place after wrapping up her run as "Fang" on the American Gladiators reboot.
Reward for Return: Literally any booking that lasts longer than one week.
AEW MISSING PERSON
Serena Deeb
Last Seen: Competing in the ROH Women’s Pure Title Tournament back in November 2025 (and hasn't appeared on main AEW TV since November 2024).
Suspected Whereabouts: Collecting paychecks under contract, working behind the scenes as a coach, and taking the occasional indie booking while "The Professor" waits for another call-up.
Reward for Return: A 15-minute technical clinic on Collision.

🚨 BONUS UPDATE: FOUND! 🚨

SPECIAL CASE CLOSED
Ash By Elegance — FOUND!
The Story: For months, the #1 question in wrestling fan groups has been: "Where in the world is Ash By Elegance?" After abruptly relinquishing the TNA Knockouts World Championship and going completely radio silent, fans were genuinely worried—especially after news broke of her scary ICU hospitalizations and Crohn’s disease diagnosis earlier this year.
The Good News: She officially broke her silence on TMZ’s Inside the Ring with the ultimate plot twist—announcing that she is 32 weeks pregnant with a baby boy (already named Kairos) and that her pregnancy has actually put her Crohn’s into remission! Huge congratulations to Ash on the amazing news. You can officially take her off the milk carton.

JaySin

Co-Founder & Co-Owner of WrestleVoice.com, Creator & Co-Host of “Discuss TNA IMPACT”. 15+ years dominating pro wrestling media (podcasting, writing, owning). Recently featured in Orlando Voyager’s “Change-Makers” series. Autism awareness advocate & mentor. Sports junkie, movie buff, gambling enthusiast, and huge nerd at heart!

https://WrestleVoice.com
Previous
Previous

Chloe Yummy Capitalizes on the GTA VI Hype Wave

Next
Next

Master AEW and ROH Roster Hub: Live Updated